SMART Recovery: What's the Difference?

Photo by Tammah Watts


WHAT’S THE DIFFERENCE? 

By Tammah Watts

We are now offering MiraCosta students a Recovery Support Group that is SMART Recovery informed and facilitated by a licensed counselor from the Health Services Department.

Some of you have been asking, “What’s the difference between SMART Recovery Support Groups and 12-Step Recovery Support Groups?”

First, I’d like to share with you how these programs are SIMILAR:

BOTH ARE:
  • Free
  • Confidential
  • Diverse
  • Available in in-person and online formats
  • Able to offer Verification of Attendance for legal and other needs
  • Structured to promote learning from others with similar challenges and goals
  • Facilitated by non-profit organizations locally, nationally, and internationally
  • Recognized by governmental and private entities including SAMSHA, NIH, and academia

Next, I’d like to share with you the primary DIFFERENCES between the two recovery support models:

SMART Recovery (Self-Management And Recovery Training):

  • Established in 1994
  • FOCUS: Self-empowerment, Courage, Activity
  • FOUNDATION: Scientific and evidenced-based
  • PURPOSE: Based on individual goals
  • PRINCIPLES: 4-Point Program: 1) Building and maintaining motivation, 2) Coping with urges, 3) Managing thoughts, feelings, and behaviors, and 4) Living a balanced lifestyle utilizing cognitive behavioral methods and problem-solving
  • EMPHASIS: “The power of CHOICE”
  • ADDICTION AS A DISEASE: Up to the participant
  • ACCEPTANCE OF MODERATION: Up to the participant
  • Non-confrontational
  • Motivational methods
  • Can complement other treatment modalities
  • Encourages conversations, healthy social interactions, and group activities
  • No sponsors
  • Focused on preventing maladaptive behaviors, not labels (alcoholic, drug addict etc.)
  • No counting days requirement
  • No hierarchy
  • Promotes the sharing of everyone’s experiences
  • Avoids direct advice giving
  • No lifetime attendance requirement

12-STEP Recovery (Alcoholics Anonymous or AA):

  • Established in 1935
  • FOCUS: Serenity, Acceptance of Powerlessness, Higher Power
  • FOUNDATION: Spiritual-based; Religious and use of God
  • PURPOSE: Abstinence
  • PRINCIPLES: 12 Steps
  • EMPHASIS: Admit powerlessness over alcohol and other addictions. Use of prayer and meditation and seeking help from higher power.
  • ADDICTION AS A DISEASE: Yes
  • ACCEPTANCE OF MODERATION: No
  • Listening to speaker
  • Use of sponsors
  • Use of labels to identify problem
  • Promotes counting/monitoring days of sobriety
  • Encourages lifetime attendance
  • Hierarchy of leadership/meetings

I hope that this introductory overview about the differences between SMART Recovery and 12-Step Recovery has been helpful.

The MiraCosta College SMART Recovery Support Group is offered every Wednesday from 12pm-1pm via Zoom. Please reach out to Health Services at 760.795.6675 if you have any questions or would like additional information.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Hiring Health Services Peer Educators!

Image
Are you thinking about a career in public health, nursing or mental health? Students, come work with us! Health Services is looking to hire motivated, energetic and responsible students to represent us on campus. Hours: 10 hours/week (commitment of a MINIMUM of 5 hours/week each week) Pay: $15.50 - Federal Work Study eligible but not needed (DACA-recipients welcome) Schedule: Weekly staff meetings/trainings are on the Oceanside campus. The remainder of hours will be scheduled based on your availability, Monday-Friday. Location: Oceanside, San Elijo, and occasional remote projects Job Summary: Under the supervision of a Mental Health Counselor and Licensed Clinical Social Worker, Peer Educators act as the bridge between Health Services and MiraCosta students. Ideal Students: Interested in exploring a career in mental health, social work, nursing, public health, and related professions. Interested in supporting the MiraCosta College student body. Passionate about reducing stigma ar
Read more

Here’s why you shouldn’t test for COVID

Image
  By Kim Marquardt, RN MSN This blog post is from the Nurse Kim archives of myth busting. I want to share some "alternative" or maybe just lesser known health and wellness viewpoints for you to chew on. *These posts are not intended as official medical advice. They ARE meant to be fun, informative, and thought provoking, hopefully sparking an interest for you to do your own research (you can start with the links I provide!) and discover the marvels of the human body, and how it can function at its optimal performance level if we understand how it works and interacts with our environment and our diet. I have a passion for health and wellness through lifestyle and nutrition and have done thousands of hours of research in addition to being a registered nurse for 23 years. I have done A LOT of self-experimentation in and around diet, lifestyle, body care, and supplementation and have spent a lot of time looking into the science behind it all (or lack thereof!). Check back weekly
Read more

Providing Support for Loved Ones Experiencing Intimate Partner Violence

Image
  by Nidya Ramirez Ibarra, LMFT Nidya Ramirez Ibarra is a bilingual (English/Spanish) Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist who grew up in Escondido, CA. An immigrant and past community organizer, Nidya utilizes her knowledge and years of experience as a therapist to co-create a space to initiate change, gain insight, build skills, and establish support. Prior to joining the mental health team at MiraCosta College, among Nidya’s experiences was working for 8 years at a local non-profit with families, individuals, and children struggling with trauma due to intimate partner violence and sexual abuse. In addition to working with student in individual, relationship, and family counseling sessions, Nidya also facilitates MiraCosta’s UPRISE support group for undocumented/ mixed status students and their loved ones. It can be difficult to find out that someone you care about is suffering from intimate partner violence and abuse. The dominant narrative in society says that to be helpful you m
Read more